Skip to main content

Rejection in My Mailbox, or Was It

I walked in the house the other day and found the mail sorted on the kitchen counter. Husband had pulled it out of the mailbox and left a stack for me and a stack for No. 2 accordingly. I don't get a lot of mail addressed solely to me except for catalogs—and boy, do I ever get the catalogs—so I was excited. I recognized the SASE right away, the one I had sent to a literary agent just four weeks before. They tell you to include a SASE so they can more easily reply to your submission. This reply was a rejection, but the blow was softened because the other item in my stack was my membership card for MENSA. So, take that, you loser agent who doesn't know real marketable talent even when it lands on your desk in the form of three chapters and a query letter. Who wins today? I do.

If you were hanging around here last year, you may remember my writing a novel I called Maryann. I have since retitled it Mrs. Branch and have started looking for an agent. I have sent inquiries to seven or eight agents, and so far I have seven or eight rejections, although several of them haven't actually responded despite the SASE. I take their silence as a "no."

I am not discouraged at this stage in my hunt for representation. I have been reading up on famous authors and their rejections and have found I am in good company. Even the most successful authors weren't always valued by publishers, and in the beginning, they had to hunt with submission after hopeful submission just like I do.

J. K. Rowling received at least 12 rejections for her first Harry Potter book. Stephen King collected at least 25 before Carrie found a publisher. When The Diary of Anne Frank was being sent around, one publisher replied, "The girl doesn't, it seems to me, have a special perception or feeling which would lift that book above the 'curiosity' level." The book has since sold more than 25 million copies. One of Dr. Seuss's rejection letters read, "too different from other juveniles on the market to warrant its selling." Humph.

Margaret Mitchell braved 38 rejections to have Gone With the Wind published. Richard Hooker had to ship out 18 submissions for M*A*S*H before he finally found a publisher. Kurt Vonnegut, D. H. Lawrence, Ray Bradbury, Judy Blume, e.e. cummings, Rudyard Kipling, Beatrix Potter, Agatha Christie, Oscar Wilde, Joseph Heller—they all received vast numbers of rejections before seeing their books in print.

I think if they can stick with it, then so can I. When you put seven or eight rejections in perspective, that really isn't very many, and if I intend to join the ranks of the likes of Jack Kerouac, George Orwell, and H. G. Wells, then I have a lot more submissions to mail out. And while I am waiting for just the right agent to say "yes," I've got my MENSA card to remind me that I'm not an idiot. As if.

As if I need a card to tell me that.

Comments

dive said…
I love Maryann, Robyn and none of us are in any doubt as to your being a smart cookie.
Keep all of your rejections lips. Authors like to get them out and read them smugly when eventually they do get published (as I know you will be, smartypants).
dive said…
Rejections lips?
I am once again resident in typo hell. Hey ho.
You and me both, Robyn. They'll be laughing on the other side of their...bank balance one day, we'll see. I've not sent mine off for a while, though recently directed an agent to my blog where my novel is. "No, thank you, you can certainly write, but it's not for me."
Well i hadn't intended it for him, it's for the customers of bookshops. Pah! Let's just keep going. Good luck!
Scout said…
Dive, "rejections lips" conjures up some interesting imagery, especially if you insert an apostrophe to make it possessive. hee hee.

Lynn, Yes, let's just keep going. I've got another package ready to go out right now!
Mrs. G. said…
Put that rejection slip up on the wall where you can see it. It represents action and power. Keep on truckin'!
Going back a while of course, but the Bronte sisters had to become men to get published. I've got a hat, can you get a suit, Robyn? We'll take turns using it.
Scout said…
Mrs. G, it IS a badge. I"m keeping them all in a folder, a red one.

Lynn, I had forgotten about what the Bronte sisters had to do. They weren't alone.
Gina said…
They don't know what they're doing half of the time, so it is good to not take the rejections personally.

Best of luck, Robyn!
Lulubelle B said…
My brother collected rejections from the New Yorker magazine. Covered a wall with them. Said they kept him motivated. Twenty years on, they still haven't bought his work, but others have and rejections are no longer an issue.

And congrats on MENSA. I guess now you're a card-carrying brainiac. :-)
hang in there Robyn. Send me a copy and I'll have my people take a looksy. :))
Anonymous said…
Fascinating! Congratulations on your MENSA card Robyn. I'm suitably humbled to be in such grand company. I haven't read "Mrs Branch" yet but I will, soon, I hope.
Maria said…
I can beat you. I have 14 rejections from agents. I have since discovered a friend of mine who DOES have an agent and she has given me a few tips. But...even she admits that what got her in was mostly that the agent was a friend of one of her college professors who liked her work. It helps to have an "in" I believe.

And yes, I have a list of all my favorite authors (including Stephen King, J.K. and Seuss) with the number of rejections slips. I once even went to a talk in which Anne Lamott read a personal thank you to an agent for rejecting her and the agent was IN the audience. I thought that was hysterically funny.

Popular posts from this blog

Am I Stupid, or What?

In two weeks, I will climb up into a charter bus, take my assigned seat, and ride 22 hours straight to Orlando, Florida. I will be a chaperon with the high school marching band, which will perform at Disney's Magic Kingdom--me and 180 people on four big buses for seven days. We will travel together, eat together, play together, fall down exhausted together--and after 22 hours, I suspect stink to high heaven together. Because of the crazy schedule, we will leave Ohio at 6 pm, travel all night and most of the next day, and spend several hours at MGM Studios before ending up at the hotel sometime after 7 pm. After I check in with the eight girls I am to supervise, I intend to shower and shower and shower. I intend to wear clean clothes and socks and brush my teeth until my toothbrush wears out. Of all the things I could be concerned about on this trip, being dirty seems to weigh heaviest on my mind. One of my eight charges could run off and do bad things with her boyfriend, but I'...

No More Mr. Nice Guy

It's good to be a nice person--to say nice things, to do nice things, to write nice things--but I declare an end to the use of the word nice. Nice is what you say when you can't think of any other adjective. Someone shows you a picture of their back yard--that's nice. Someone tells you about their afternoon adventure--that's nice. Or someone describes their childhood in great detail and sometimes with painstaking effort--that's nice. It's a lazy word, and it's non-descriptive. Nice is like mashed potatoes with noodles and chicken gravy all in a big pile on one plate with some canned corn for garnish. Everything is the same color and texture and base substance--starch (this is a favorite Amish dish). Nice is like a partly cloudy day in April when outside feels like inside, and you can't tell a difference between the lighting and the temperature of your living room and the lighting and temperature of your front yard. Nice is a glass of lukewarm water. ...

An Offending Pile

So, I'm standing in my living room letting my mind wander for a minute or two as I stare out the window and watch the day go by, and I see my neighbors walking their dogs down the street. They are nice neighbors who are always friendly and responsible with their property. That is to say they aren't like the other neighbors who heap rubbish behind their house like Ma and Pa Kettle and let their dogs bark for thirty minutes at a time . Anyway, I see the nice people walking their dogs, a big golden retriever who is as sweet as can be and as dumb as a post—he once ate a sock and nearly died before it was surgically removed—and a new golden retriever puppy. Then I see Neighbor Wife suddenly run down the street with the big dog. Then I see Neighbor Husband stopped in front of my house with the puppy on its leash. And then I see the puppy taking a huge dump in my grass. Let me tell you, that is not done in this town unless the dog owner has a plastic bag handy and is ready to pick up ...